The Days of Our Lives universe has been buzzing with intense speculation this week — and fans can’t stop talking about the growing rumor

that Ashley Puzemis, who brilliantly portrays Holly Jonas, might be on her way out of DOOL. But what’s even more shocking is the twist

attached to this supposed exit: sources suggest that while Ashley may be leaving the show, Holly as a character will remain in Salem — potentially with a brand-new face.

 

 

Could one of Days of Our Lives’ most promising young stars be preparing for a major change? Let’s break down the facts, fan theories, and insider clues fueling this wild speculation.

Ashley Puzemis’ Impact as Holly Jonas

 

 

Since stepping into the role of Holly Jonas, Ashley Puzemis has made an unforgettable impression on both the audience and her fellow castmates. Her performance captured the emotional complexity of Holly — the daughter of the beloved Nicole Walker and Daniel Jonas — navigating trauma, love, and identity in the heart of Salem’s chaos.

 

 

In just a short span, Ashley turned Holly into more than just a supporting character. She became a central emotional anchor for storylines involving Nicole’s return, the mysterious paternity of Tesoro, and the ongoing drama surrounding Sophia and Melinda’s schemes.

Fans praised Ashley for bringing warmth and vulnerability to the role. Her tearful scenes with Arianne Zucker (Nicole) have been described as “pure gold” — deeply moving and completely authentic. But now, whispers from behind the scenes suggest that her journey may soon come to an unexpected halt.

 

 

Rumors Begin: Ashley Puzemis’ Alleged Exit

The rumors first began circulating on social media after a production insider reportedly leaked that Ashley’s “contract renewal was still under discussion.” According to this source, the show’s creative team has been considering “a time jump or storyline refresh” that could involve recasting Holly with an older actress to push the character into more mature plotlines.

That speculation quickly snowballed when Ashley was noticeably absent from several recent DOOL set photos shared by cast members. Even more telling, her name was missing from the updated cast call sheet posted online last week.

Fans were quick to panic, flooding X (formerly Twitter) and Reddit with questions like, “Is Ashley really leaving?” and “What’s going to happen to Holly?”

So far, neither Ashley nor NBC has made an official statement — which only adds fuel to the fire.

Will Holly Be Recast Instead of Written Out?

Here’s where the rumors take a fascinating turn. While it seems Ashley’s time on the show might be coming to an end, several insiders insist that Holly Jonas will not be leaving Salem.

Instead, Days of Our Lives may be gearing up for another recast. The decision would reportedly allow writers to age up the character slightly and open new romantic or dramatic storylines — particularly following Nicole’s explosive return and Tesoro’s shocking paternity twist.

If this is true, it would follow the long-standing DOOL tradition of recasting key characters rather than writing them off completely. Fans will remember how characters like Ciara Brady, Will Horton, and even EJ DiMera have been recast multiple times — each new actor bringing their own interpretation while preserving the legacy of the role.

The idea of a recast has already divided fans. Some insist Ashley’s portrayal is irreplaceable, while others are open to seeing where a slightly older Holly might take the story.