Emmerdale has never been short on suspense, but the latest storyline involving Killer John has fans sitting on the edge of their seats. After

a string of terrifying events that rocked the village, viewers are convinced they’ve cracked the code on who John’s next victim will be. And

according to fan theories, it’s not the person anyone expected.

 

 

The Rise of Killer John

John arrived in Emmerdale under mysterious circumstances, charming some villagers while making others deeply uneasy. At first, he blended into the fabric of the community, offering a façade of helpfulness and humility. But beneath the surface, John’s darker tendencies slowly began to show.

His violent outbursts, cryptic remarks, and suspicious behavior fueled rumors that he wasn’t who he claimed to be. The shocking moment when John was revealed as a killer confirmed viewers’ worst fears: a predator was living in their midst.

 

 

Now, with one victim already gone and the police hot on his trail, speculation has reached fever pitch about who he’ll target next.

Fan Theories Take Over Social Media

Emmerdale fans have been analyzing every scene for clues, posting theories across social media platforms and fan forums. Many insist the show has left a breadcrumb trail pointing toward John’s next move.

One fan wrote: “It’s obvious he’s circling around someone unexpected. The writers won’t go for the obvious choice—it’ll be a shock twist!” Another commented: “John is obsessed with control. His next victim will be someone who challenges his authority.”

While some initially assumed John would target Aaron or Mack’s loved ones in revenge, fans now believe the writers are steering in a different, more surprising direction.

The Unlikely Target

According to growing speculation, John’s next victim could be April Windsor. This shocking theory has stunned the fandom, as April is young, vulnerable, and seemingly unrelated to John’s personal vendettas.

Fans argue that April’s role as a curious and brave character has put her in harm’s way. She has been asking questions around the village, poking into matters others prefer to leave alone. If John perceives her curiosity as a threat, she could become his next target.

Others suggest that April’s involvement would raise the emotional stakes, uniting the village in fear and grief while showcasing John’s ruthlessness.

Other Possible Victims

Not all fans agree on April. Some believe John may go after Charity Dingle, given her sharp instincts and history of confronting shady newcomers. Charity has already voiced suspicions about John, and taking her down would eliminate a major threat to his secrecy.

Another name circulating is Moira Dingle. As Mack’s sister and one of the strongest figures in the village, Moira represents defiance and resilience—qualities that might provoke John into making her his next target.

Still, others argue that John’s twisted psychology means his choice won’t be based on logic but rather opportunity. In soap fashion, the next victim could be someone caught in the wrong place at the wrong time.