‘1883’ Star Reveals He’s Not a Fan of the Original Show: “I Don’t Watch Yellowstone”
His commentary reveals a divide between the traditional Western vision and its modern, commercial, and dramatized interpretations.
With his signature velvety baritone and mustache, Sam Elliott has become a living icon of the Western genre. He seems to have descended from the hills to play rugged cowboys and wise elders.
Therefore, his return to his roots in the prequel series 1883 was

This observation perfectly captures the essence of the debate over the nature of Yellowstone’s success. Critics often accuse Taylor Sheridan’s show of being overly melodramatic, clichéd, and reliant on the formulas of old primetime soap operas.
Thus, Elliott, whose image is inextricably linked to the classic, authentic Western, distances himself from Yellowstone’s more glamorous, modern take on the genre.
This is not the first time the actor has criticized modern Westerns. He previously found himself at the center of a controversy over his comments about Jane Campion’s Oscar-winning movie, The Power of the Dog.
Elliott claimed that the New Zealand director was unqualified to discuss the American West and disapproved of the film’s homosexual subtext. He later apologized for his comments.
The Power of the Dog is a profound psychological exploration of toxic masculinity and the nature of violence that critics and audiences alike hailed as a masterpiece.
In 1883, in which Elliott plays a key role, the history of Western exploration is examined in a stark and uncompromising manner.
Set 130 years before the events of Yellowstone, it chronicles the journey of John Dutton’s great-grandfather, James, his family, and a group of immigrants as they travel through dangerous territories in search of a better life.
Elliott plays Shea Brennan, a Civil War veteran who is hired as a caravan guide. It is a story of hardship and death, and the price these pioneers paid so their descendants could build an empire.
met with applause and earned him a Screen Actors Guild Award.
His commentary reveals a divide between the traditional Western vision and its modern, commercial, and dramatized interpretations.
With his signature velvety baritone and mustache, Sam Elliott has become a living icon of the Western genre. He seems to have descended from the hills to play rugged cowboys and wise elders.
Therefore, his return to his roots in the prequel series 1883 was
This observation perfectly captures the essence of the debate over the nature of Yellowstone’s success. Critics often accuse Taylor Sheridan’s show of being overly melodramatic, clichéd, and reliant on the formulas of old primetime soap operas.
Thus, Elliott, whose image is inextricably linked to the classic, authentic Western, distances himself from Yellowstone’s more glamorous, modern take on the genre.
This is not the first time the actor has criticized modern Westerns. He previously found himself at the center of a controversy over his comments about Jane Campion’s Oscar-winning movie, The Power of the Dog.
Elliott claimed that the New Zealand director was unqualified to discuss the American West and disapproved of the film’s homosexual subtext. He later apologized for his comments.
The Power of the Dog is a profound psychological exploration of toxic masculinity and the nature of violence that critics and audiences alike hailed as a masterpiece.
In 1883, in which Elliott plays a key role, the history of Western exploration is examined in a stark and uncompromising manner.
Set 130 years before the events of Yellowstone, it chronicles the journey of John Dutton’s great-grandfather, James, his family, and a group of immigrants as they travel through dangerous territories in search of a better life.
Elliott plays Shea Brennan, a Civil War veteran who is hired as a caravan guide. It is a story of hardship and death, and the price these pioneers paid so their descendants could build an empire.
met with applause and earned him a Screen Actors Guild Award.