Fans of classic Days know the complicated and tragic history of Marlena and her twin sister Samantha. Samantha, who struggled with

identity crises, emotional trauma, and a series of controversial choices, was ultimately killed off in a storyline that sent shockwaves across

Salem. For years, her death has been considered one of the most tragic losses in the Evans family.

 

 

So how is Andrea Hall returning?

Sources close to production hint that the writers are planning a storyline so bold, so dramatic, and so quintessentially soap-operatic that it will reignite decades-old plotlines and open the floodgates for an entirely new generation of Evans family drama.

Yes—Samantha may not be dead after all.

 

Or at least, not in the way fans were led to believe.

The Clues: Has Days Been Setting This Up for Months?

Astute viewers have pointed out that the show has been dropping subtle breadcrumbs:

Marlena mentioning her sister more frequently

 

 

Strange references to “unfinished family business”

A mysterious figure seen in a recent promo, whose silhouette looked strikingly like Marlena

Rumors of a major Evans family arc planned for 2026

While DOOL is notorious for crafting long-planned surprises, this twist may be one of its most ambitious yet.

And yes, the theory gaining the most traction online is that Samantha Evans survived—her death faked, covered up, or manipulated by a now-familiar Salem villain. Stefano DiMera’s name has already resurfaced in fan discussions, even posthumously, because if anyone could orchestrate a twin switch, hidden survival, memory wipe, or secret imprisonment… it’s Stefano.

Why Andrea Hall’s Return Matters Now

Deidre Hall, who has embodied Marlena for more than four decades, recently hinted at retirement discussions. While she has not announced any official plans to exit the show, fans have been preparing emotionally for the possibility.

Andrea Hall’s comeback might be the show’s way of preserving the Evans legacy in Salem—even if Marlena eventually transitions out of the center spotlight.

Producers reportedly see Andrea’s return as:

A tribute to the Evans family history

A way to deepen Marlena’s storylines

A potential setup for a “dual storyline arc” between the sisters

A chance to explore long-buried secrets connected to the DiMeras

If Andrea’s Samantha returns, she won’t just be Marlena’s twin—she will be a wildcard, one who may have suffered decades of trauma, manipulation, or imprisonment.

A woman like that doesn’t reenter Salem quietly.

What Role Will Andrea Play? Samantha? Someone New?

Fans are debating two big possibilities:

Andrea reprises Samantha Evans, revealing she has been alive all this time.

Andrea returns as an entirely new character, similar to her previous portrayal of Hattie Adams.

Some insiders claim the writers are leaning toward Samantha’s resurrection, because it offers more emotional weight and long-term payoff. Marlena confronting a twin she believed dead would create explosive drama:

Guilt

Shock

Anger

Love

And fear—because a traumatized Samantha may not be the gentle soul Marlena once knew

How Will Marlena React? A Storm of Emotions Ahead

If Marlena learns her sister is alive, her world will turn upside down.

Expect scenes filled with:

Marlena questioning her memories

John Black stepping in to protect her

The DiMeras exploiting the twin reunion

Conflicts over identity, trust, and painful family history

A possible “who is who?” confusion shocker

And fans know Days never misses a chance to unleash a good twin switch storyline.

A New Golden Era for the Evans Family?

Andrea Hall’s comeback signals something big—possibly the start of a major Evans-centered arc the show hasn’t explored in years. With Marlena’s future uncertain and fans craving deeper family storytelling, this twist could reshape Salem for the next decade.